Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology

Official Journal of the Italian Society of Orthopaedics and Traumatology

Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology Cover Image
Open Access

A novel modification of Bosworth's technique to repair zone I Achilles tendon ruptures

  • Avadhanam Pavan Kumar1Email author,
  • Raviprakash Shashikiran2 and
  • Choulapalle Raghuram2
Journal of Orthopaedics and TraumatologyOfficial Journal of the Italian Society of Orthopaedics and Traumatology201314:222

https://doi.org/10.1007/s10195-012-0222-y

Received: 16 November 2011

Accepted: 20 December 2012

Published: 11 January 2013

Abstract

Background

Zone I ruptures of the Achilles tendon and chronic ruptures in zone II with a gap of more than 6 cm are difficult to treat. We describe a technique that is very well suited to this type of rupture.

Materials and methods

Seventy-eight patients with chronic rupture of the Achilles tendon were operated on between January 1996 and December 2010. We used a modification of the Bosworth technique in which a strip of the gastrocnemius aponeurosis was taken, made into a tendon-like structure and passed through the calcaneum after making a drill hole; then it was sutured back to the proximal stump. The Leppilahti scoring system was used to evaluate these patients.

Results

Sixty-two patients had excellent results, 8 had good results, 4 had fair results, 2 had poor results, and 2 were lost to follow-up at the end of 1 year. Nearly all patients resumed work at 6 months postoperatively, had normal walking and stair climbing, and regained normal dorsiflexion.

Conclusion

Our technique is ideally suited to zone I ruptures (where no distal stump is available for repair) and ruptures in zone II where end-to-end repair is not possible.

Keywords

Achilles tendon Chronic rupture Strip of the gastrocnemius aponeurosis Zone I ruptures

Introduction

Zone I of the Achilles tendon is the area from the calcaneal insertion to 2 cm above it. Ruptures and avulsions in this area are very common in patients with chronic tendinitis, peritendinitis, retrocalcaneal bursitis and a history of steroid injection at that level. Ruptures of the Achilles tendon in zone II (2–6 cm from the calcaneal insertion) that have been neglected for a long time have a distal stump that is not suitable for repair. Furthermore, neglected ruptures of the Achilles tendon pose a difficult problem, i.e., wide separation of the ruptured tendinous ends that cannot be repaired by end-to-end anastomosis even if the stump is available.

Several surgical procedures have been described with the objective of bridging this gap by grafting and thus restoring the continuity of the tendon. One or more Achilles tendon strips [1], the fascia lata [2] and tendons from the plantaris [3], peroneus brevis [4], flexor digitorum longus [5], flexor hallucis longus [6] or posterior tibial [7] tendons were the grafts utilized in these procedures. Synthetic materials, such as carbon fiber [8] or Dacron polyester [9], have also been used as scaffolding for the repair. All these studies described repair of the Achilles tendon in zone II. We could not identify articles on the management of zone I Achilles tendon ruptures and neglected ruptures with gaps of more than 6 cm. Most of the studies described the repair of the Achilles tendon with other small tendons. These small tendons do not have sufficient strength compared to the original Achilles tendon, and the surgical repair compromised the original function of the tendon.

The main objective of this study was to describe a novel technique of Achilles tendon repair suitable for ruptures in zone I and chronic ruptures in zone II where end-to-end repair is not possible. The outcomes were assessed with clinical and ultrasonographic evaluation.

Materials and methods

From January 1996 through December 2010, 78 patients with long-standing rupture of the Achilles tendon were treated with the operative technique to be described (Table 1). All the patients gave informed consent prior to being included in the study. The study was approved by the local ethics committee and performed according to the Declaration of Helsinki. There were 48 men and 30 women with the ages ranging from 38 to 66 years. The duration of follow-up ranged from 6 months to 1 year. Forty-four patients had a history of previous injections of steroids around the Achilles tendon by other physicians for presumed tendinitis or retro-calcaneal bursitis. Fourteen patients had a history of severe trauma caused by sudden dorsiflexion of the foot. Twenty patients had a trivial traumas resulting in painful ankles and came without any history of steroid injection.
Table 1

Study overview

Characteristics

Value

Total no. of patients

78

Sex ratio M:F

48:30

Duration of follow-up

1 year

Zone I ruptures

72

Zone II ruptures

6

Mechanism of injury

 Steroid intake

44

 Severe trauma

14

 Trivial trauma

20

The duration of the symptoms ranged from 3 to 36 months. None of the cases were compound ruptures. All the patients had difficulty walking and pain around the ankle. Seventy of 78 patients were manual laborers; the other 8 patients were homemakers.

Because of the chronicity of the symptoms, none of the patients had ecchymosis, swelling and point tenderness, which are commonly associated with an acute rupture. There was only moderate swelling and edema around the posterior aspect of the ankle, but all patients had major weakness of active plantar flexion and a limp. In 55 patients, the defect in the Achilles tendon was visible or palpable. Usually there was some tenderness about the proximal and distal stumps of the ruptured tendon. The Thompson test was positive in all patients (that is, squeezing of the calf did not result in plantar flexion of the foot). Plain radiographs revealed Achilles tendon rupture by the gap between the tendon ends and presence of calcification in the distal portion of the proximal stump of the Achilles tendon.

All patients had undergone an ultrasound scan of the Achilles tendon to confirm the rupture. Seventy-two patients had a rupture in zone I (rupture within 2 cm of the calcaneal insertion). Six patients had a rupture in zone II (rupture 2 to 6 cm from the calcaneal insertion). The patients who received steroid injection had an avulsion of the tendon from the calcaneum. Intraoperatively, patients had necrosis of the tendon end, which was confirmed histologically. Calcification of the tendon along with necrosis was seen in a few patients.

Operative technique

The procedure was performed with the patient in semi-prone position and under general or spinal anesthesia with the use of tourniquet control. We used a straight midline incision starting proximally 10–12 cm below the knee joint (Fig. 1). This incision was continued distally and then gently curved laterally, distal to the insertion of the tendon. The length of the incision was 15–20 cm, sufficient for the exposure necessary to see the lesion completely and to execute the repair. After the skin incision, the sural nerve and short saphenous vein were secured and isolated. A 1.5–2-cm-wide strip was cut and freed from the central portion of the raphe (Fig. 2). Proximally the gastrocnemius muscle can be stripped from the apenurosis if more apenurosis is required for repair. The raphe should be taken from the tendon carefully as the tendon rotates for 90° from medial to lateral. The raphe was left attached just 1.5 cm proximal to the rupture site. The entire raphe strip was folded on itself with the smooth surface outside and sutured to make it into a long and thick structure simulating a tendon. The processed strip of raphe was passed through the stump for better anchorage and stability (Fig. 3). A transverse hole was made 1 cm below and behind the Achilles tendon insertion into the calcaneum with a large-diameter drill bit (Fig. 4). The processed raphe was passed in a medial to lateral direction through the hole with the help of curved tendon tunneling forceps, taking care that there was free movement of the tendon in bony tunnel; it was sutured back to the main tendon (Fig. 5). While suturing, a proper amount of tension in the tendon was maintained by plantar flexing the ankle (Fig. 6). The precautions taken during surgery were (1) making the skin incision up to the tendon without subcutaneous dissection and (2) tight continuous subcutaneous suturing to prevent wound dehiscence.
Fig. 1

A long straight midline skin incision 10–12 cm below the knee joint. Isolation of the sural nerve and short saphenous vein is also seen

Fig. 2

A 1.5–2-cm-wide strip cut and freed from the central portion of the raphe. Proximally the gastrocnemius muscle can be stripped from the apenurosis if more is required for repair

Fig. 3

The processed strip of raphe passing through the stump for better anchorage and stability

Fig. 4

A transverse hole being made 1 cm below the Achilles tendon insertion in the calcaneum with a large-diameter drill bit

Fig. 5

The processed raphe being passed from medial to lateral direction through the hole with the help of curved tendon tunneling forceps

Fig. 6

The processed raphe sutured back to the tendon while plantar flexing the ankle

Postoperatively, a long, non-weight-bearing leg cast with the ankle in 20° plantar flexion and the knee in 30° flexion was applied for 4 weeks. Wound dressing was refreshed through a window over the cast 2 days after surgery. Three weeks after surgery, the sutures were removed. After 4 weeks, the knee was freed from the cast, and a short leg cast with the ankle in 20° plantar flexion was applied for 4 weeks. A walking short leg cast with the ankle plantigrade was applied for 4 more weeks and completely freed from casting after 3 months. After 3 months, gradual calf strengthening and stretching exercises were started along with weight bearing.

Evaluation

The clinical outcome was assessed at 12-week, 6-month and 1-year follow-up visits using the clinical scoring method described by Leppilahti et al. [10]. The scoring included subjective factors such as pain, stiffness, muscle weakness and footwear restrictions; subjective outcomes as well as objective factors such as the active range of ankle motion and isokinetic calf muscle strength. The maximum number of points achievable was 100. The results were classified as excellent (≥90 points), good (75–89 points), fair (60–74 points) or poor (<60 points). The patients were asked to give answers to a nonvalidated subjective symptoms questionnaire. The patients were evaluated with an ultrasound scan at 6-month follow-up.

Results

All patients were evaluated according to the Leppilahti scoring system (Table 2). Sixty-two patients had excellent results, eight had good results, and four had fair results. Two patients had poor results, and two were lost to follow-up after 1 year.
Table 2

Leppilahati scoring system

Clinical factor

Points

No. of patients at 6 months

At 1 year

Pain

 None

15

54

60

 Mild, no limitations in recreational activities

10

20

15

 Moderate, limitations in recreational, but not daily activities

5

1

1

 Severe, limitations in recreational and daily activities

0

1

0

Stiffness

 None

15

40

57

 Mild, occasional, no limitations in recreational activities

10

30

17

 Moderate, limitations in recreational, but not daily activities

5

4

2

 Severe, limitations in recreational and daily activities

0

2

0

Calf muscle weakness (subjective)

 None

15

50

70

 Mild, occasional, no limitations in recreational activities

10

24

5

 Moderate, limitations in recreational, but not daily activities

5

2

1

 Severe, limitations in recreational and daily activities

0

0

0

Footwear restrictions

 None

10

60

62

 Mild, most shoes tolerated

5

15

14

 Moderate, unable to tolerate fashionable shoes, modified shoes tolerated

0

1

0

Active range of motion (ROM) difference between ankles

 Normal (<6°)

15

55

62

 Mild (6°–10°)

10

14

7

 Moderate (11°–15°)

5

6

5

 Severe (>15°)

0

1

0

Subjective results

 Very satisfied

15

53

65

 Satisfied with minor reservations

10

21

10

 Satisfied with major reservation

5

2

1

 Dissatisfied

0

0

0

Isokinetic muscle strength (score)

 Excellent

15

69

70

 Good

10

3

4

 Fair

5

4

2

 Poor

0

0

0

Leppilahti score

 Excellent

90–100

58

62

 Good

75–89

10

8

 Fair

60–74

6

4

 Poor

<60

2

2

All patients resumed work at 6 months postoperatively. Fifteen patients had mild pain at the end of 1 year at the ankle joint, but this did not hindering their daily or recreational activities. However, one patient had moderate pain that limited him from recreational activities but not from daily activities. Mild stiffness around the ankle joint was noted in 17 patients at the end of 1 year, but this stiffness did not limit their daily or recreational activities. Two patients complained of moderate stiffness. Nearly all patients had normal walking and stair climbing. There was significant improvement in the range of ankle motion postoperatively. There was an equal range of motion in both ankles in 62 out of 76 follow-up patients at the end of 1 year. Five patients were unable to raise their heels from the floor equally when on tiptoe because of other unrelated causes such as old age and obesity. Ultrasound scanning at 6-month postoperative follow-up showed increased thickness of the processed apenurosis, and delineation between the tendon end and processed apenurosis decreased (Fig. 7).
Fig. 7

Ultrasound scan after 6 months showing continuation of fibers at the repaired site. The blue arrows show the repaired apenurosis, and the white arrows show intact tendon

Complications in our series included scar hypertrophy (in 2 patients), superficial (in 2 patients), and deep infection (in 1 patient) and delayed wound healing (in 3 patients). Superficial infection was controlled with local antibiotics and regular dressings. Deep infection required a second debridement, and then the outcome was uneventful. In three patients, there was delayed healing, and it took nearly 1 month to heal completely with regular dressings. However, none of the patients had a re-rupture of the tendon.

Discussion

A chronic rupture of the Achilles tendon causes difficulty and impairment of ankle plantar flexion. The tendon sheath often becomes thickened and adherent to the retracted ends of the tendon, and there is minimal repair tissue in the gap [7, 11, 12].

In neglected Achilles tendon ruptures, there is usually a gap between the tendon ends with retraction of the proximal stump, which results in shortening of the triceps surae muscle bellies and hence weakness of plantar flexion in the ankle. The tension that the muscle fiber can produce decreases as the fiber shortens until it becomes zero when the fiber is at approximately 60 % of its resting length. Most of the ruptures in our series had a gap of more than 6 cm (type 3 according to Meyerson’s classification and type 4 according to Kuwada’s classification [13]). Such cases cannot be treated conservatively, and surgical management is necessary to obtain normal range of ankle motion. The purpose of our study was to manage the Achilles tendon ruptures in zone I and chronic ruptures in zone II where end-to-end repair is not possible.

The etiology of Achilles tendon rupture remains unclear, but some investigations have proposed that chronic degenerative changes are a common cause based on the histological examination of the material obtained from the ruptured area during surgery [14, 15]. In our study, 64 patients sustained rupture of the Achilles tendon because of trivial trauma; of these, 44 patients had received local steroid injections for painful ankles. The remaining 20 patients with trivial ruptures had a history of long-term ankle pain. This suggests that most Achilles tendon ruptures are associated with chronic ankle pain (tendinitis and retrocalcaneal bursitis).

Balasubramaniam et al. [16] stated that injection of steroids into the tendon insertions caused necrosis at the site of injection and a delayed healing response. The anti-inflammatory and analgesic properties of corticosteroids may mask the symptoms of tendon damage, inducing individuals to maintain high levels of activity even when the tendon is damaged [17].

According to Langergran and Lindholm [18], the Achilles tendon is divided into three zones based on vascularity. Zone I is <3 cm from the calcaneal insertion, zone II 3–6 cm from the calcaneal insertion and zone III >6 cm from the calcaneal insertion. Most of the ruptures in our series were in zone I, with a negligible amount of distal stump present for end-to-end repair.

The techniques for repair or reconstruction of the neglected rupture can be broadly classified as end-to-end repair, Achilles tendon advancement or flap reconstruction, local tendon transfer and implantation (autograft, allograft or synthetic). According to Myerson, defects that are no more than 1–2 cm long can be managed with end-to-end repair and a posterior compartment fasciotomy. A gap up to 5 cm can be managed with V–Y lengthening, with or without a tendon transfer. When the space between tendon ends is >5 cm, it can be bridged with using a tendon transfer, alone or in combination with a V–Y advancement. However, when the rupture is in zone 1, end-to-end repair is not possible even though the gap between tendon ends is less than 2 cm. In such situations, our technique is ideal [19].

When the space between the tendon ends is ≥5 cm, bridging the gap with any other technique is tedious. With V–Y lengthening [20], gaps up to 5 cm can be repaired, but calf weakness is the main disadvantage. V–Y lengthening is not suitable when the gap is more than 6 cm.

Bosworth repaired Achilles tendon rupture by taking a wide strip of the proximal aponeurosis, which was woven through the proximal and distal tendon stumps. This repair needed some amount of distal stump for repair. This method is not ideally suited to ruptures in zone I. We modified the Bosworth technique by passing the apenurosis through the calcaneum instead of passing it through the distal stump and suturing it back to the main tendon, thus making it a good option for avulsions and ruptures in zone I [21].

White and Kraynick first reported a neglected rupture that was reconstructed with a peroneus brevis transfer to the calcaneus and reinforced with fascial strips. Teuffer described passing the peroneus brevis tendon through the calcaneus, across the repair site, and suturing it to the proximal Achilles tendon. Turco and Spinella augmented end-to-end repair of the Achilles tendon with a modification of Teuffer’s technique by passing the peroneus brevis through the distal tendon stump rather than the calcaneus [22, 23]. Two concerns, however, have been raised about this technique: first, the potential for eversion weakness. Secondly, because the tendon was placed distally in a lateral to medial direction, it did not duplicate the medial pull of the normal Achilles tendon.

Mann et al. [5] used the FDL to bridge the gap in chronic Achilles tendon ruptures. The FDL tendon was harvested in the midfoot, and the distal stump was sutured to the FHL. They also included a proximal fascial turndown flap in all cases and, when the length allowed, the proximal stump was reattached to the calcaneus with a pullout wire technique. This technique is not suitable when the gap between the ends is more than 5 cm.

Wapner et al. [6] reported on eight neglected ruptures that were reconstructed with the FHL transfer harvested from the midfoot. The main disadvantage of this technique is that the tendon is very thin in diameter, and it alone will not be adequate.

In our technique, we used aponeurosis of the gastronemius itself, thereby not needing tendon transfers, which would compromise the function of that tendon. As we were using the same tendon apenurosis, the strength remained balanced. Our technique would be ideal for a gap of more than 6 cm that needs tendon transfer with additional synthetic grafts.

Since this study is not prospective or randomized, the results cannot be considered conclusive. The best scientific conclusion can be derived if this method of repair is compared with other methods of repair. We had a limited follow-up period. Longer follow-up is needed to assess the long-term complications associated with our technique.

Our technique is ideally suited for chronic ruptures in zone I (where no distal stump is available for repair) and ruptures that have a large gap of more than 6 cm. This is accomplished with a single incision, with a good postoperative range of ankle motion and function.

Declarations

Conflict of interest

None.

Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.

Authors’ Affiliations

(1)
Chalmeda Anada Rao Institute of Medical Sciences
(2)
Department of Orthopaedics, Chalmeda Anada Rao Institute of Medical Sciences

References

  1. Maffulli N, Ajis A (2008) Management of chronic ruptures of the Achilles tendon. J Bone Joint Surg Am 90(6):1348–1360PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
  2. Zadek I (1940) Repair of old ruptures of the tendo Achillis by means of fascia lata: report of a case. J Bone Joint Surg Am 22:1070–1071Google Scholar
  3. Kissel CG, Blacklidge DK, Crowley DL (1994) Repair of neglected Achilles tendon ruptures—procedure and functional results. J Foot Ankle Surg 33:46–52PubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. Miskulin M, Miskulin A, Klobucar H, Kuvalja S (2005) Neglected rupture of the Achilles tendon treated with peroneus brevis transfer: a functional assessment of 5 cases. J Foot Ankle Surg 44:49–56PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
  5. Mann RA, Holmes GB Jr, Seale KS, Collins DN (1991) Chronic rupture of the Achilles tendon: a new technique of repair. J Bone Joint Surg Am 73:214–219PubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Wapner KL, Pavlock GS, Hecht PJ, Naselli F, Walther R (1993) Repair of chronic Achilles tendon rupture with flexor hallucis longus tendon transfer. Foot Ankle 14:443–449PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
  7. Platt H (1931) Observation of some tendon repairs. Br Med J 1:611–615PubMed CentralPubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
  8. Howard CB, Winston I, Bell W, Mackie I, Jenkins DH (1984) Late repair of the calcaneal tendon with carbon fibre. J Bone Joint Surg Br 66:206–208PubMedGoogle Scholar
  9. Lieberman JR, Lozman J, Czajka J, Dougherty J (1988) Repair of Achilles tendon ruptures with Dacron vascular graft. Clin Orthop Relat Res 234:204–208PubMedGoogle Scholar
  10. Leppilahti J, Forsman K, Puranen J, Orava S (1998) Outcome and prognostic factors of Achilles rupture using a new scoring method. Clin Othop 346:152–161Google Scholar
  11. Leslie HD, Edwards WH (2005) Neglected ruptures of the Achilles tendon. Foot Ankle Clin 10:357–370PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
  12. Myerson MS (1999) Achilles tendon ruptures. Instr Course Lect 48:219–230PubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Kuwada GT (1990) Classification of tendo Achilles rupture with consideration of surgical repair techniques. J Foot Surg 29:361–365PubMedGoogle Scholar
  14. Barfred T (1971) Experimental rupture of the Achilles tendons. Acta Orthop Scand 42:406PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
  15. Kannus P, Jozsa L (1991) Histopathological changes preceding spontaneous rupture of tendon. J Bone Joint Surg Am 73:1507–1525PubMedGoogle Scholar
  16. Balasubramaniam P, Prathap K (1972) The effect of injection of hydrocortisone into rabbit calcaneal tendons. J Bone Joint Surg 54-B(4):729–734Google Scholar
  17. DiStefano VJ, Nixon JE (1973) Ruptures of the Achilles tendon. J Sports Med 1:34–37Google Scholar
  18. Langergran L, Lindholm A (1958) Vascular distribution in the Achilles tendon. Acta Chir Scand 116:491Google Scholar
  19. Myerson MS (1999) Achilles tendon ruptures. Instr Course Lect 48:219–230PubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. Abraham E, Pankovich AM (1975) Neglected rupture of the Achilles tendon. Treatment by V-Y tendinous flap. J Bone Joint Surg 57-A(2):253–255Google Scholar
  21. Bosworth DM (1956) Repair of defects of the tendoachillis. J Bone Joint Surg 38-A(1):111–114PubMedGoogle Scholar
  22. White RK, Kraynick BM (1959) Surgical uses of the peroneus brevis tendon. Surg Gynecol Obstet 108:117–121PubMedGoogle Scholar
  23. Teuffer AP (1974) Traumatic ruptures of the Achilles tendon. Reconstruction by transplant and graft using the lateral peroneus brevis. Orthop Clin N Am 5(1):89–93Google Scholar

Copyright

© The Author(s) 2013

Advertisement