Official Journal of the Italian Society of Orthopaedics and Traumatology
Table 1 Characteristics and quality of the included studies
Author | Study design | ThAs (n) | Follow-up (year) | Operative approach | Bearing surfaces material | Outcomes | Jadad score | NOS | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Liner | Head | ||||||||
Blakeney et al. [23] | RCT | 56 | 5 | Posterior | PE | Cobalt-chrome | Osteolysis; migration; revision | 5 | – |
Gallen et al. [7] | RCT | 32 | 10 | Posterior | PE | Cobalt-chrome | Osteolysis | 5 | – |
Garcia-Cimbrelo et al. [24] | Cohort study | 319 | 4.7 (3–8) | Posterior | Ceramic | Ceramic | Revision | – | 7 |
GarcÃa-Rey et al. [8] | Cohort study | 791 | 9.6 (5–15) | Posterolateral | Ceramic; PE | Ceramic; Metal | Osteolysis; migration; revision | – | 8 |
Howie et al. [17] | RCT | 66 | 2 | Posterior | PE | Cobalt-chrome | Osteolysis; translation; Rotation; HHS | 5 | – |
Iorio et al. [25] | Cohort study | 775 | 2–10 | NA | PE | NA | Osteolysis; migration; revision | – | 8 |
Merican et al. [26] | Cohort study | 115 | 2.8 (1.3–4.3) | Modified anterior | Metal | Metal | Migration; revision | – | 7 |
Minten et al. [9] | RCT | 36 | 6.5 | Posterolateral | PE | Ceramic | Translation; rotation; HHS | 5 | – |
Natera et al. [10] | Cohort study | 749 | 14.2 (8.9–16.7) | Anterior; lateral; anterolateral; posterolateral | Ceramic; PE | Ceramic; Metal | Osteolysis; revision | – | 7 |
Otten et al. [11] | RCT | 34 | 14 | Posterolateral | PE | Ceramic | Osteolysis; translation; revision; HSS | 5 | – |
Pakvis et al. [15] | RCT | 37 | 2 | Posterolateral | PE | Ceramic | Migration; translation; rotation; revision; HHS | 6 | – |
Pepe et al. [4] | Cohort study | 30 | 1 | Posterior | Ceramic; PE | Ceramic; Cobalt-chrome | Osteolysis; migration; revision; HHS | – | 7 |
Röhrl et al. [18] | RCT | 43 | 5 | Posterior | PE | Cobalt-chrome; Ceramic | Osteolysis; translation; HHS | 4 | – |
Roth et al. [27] | Cohort study | 211 | 5 | Transgluteal surgical | NA | NA | Migration | – | 7 |
Taniguchi et al. [28] | Cohort study | 209 | 7–10 | Posterolateral | PE | Cobalt-chrome | Osteolysis; migration | – | 8 |
Thanner et al. [19] | RCT | 63 | 2 | Modified Hardinge | PE | Ceramic; Cobalt-chrome | Osteolysis; migration; translation; rotation; revision; pain scores; HHS | 2 | – |
Von Schewelov et al. [29] | Cohort study | 154 | 6(0.5–12) | Lateral | PE | Cobalt-chrome | Osteolysis | – | 7 |
Weber et al. [30] | Cohort study | 127 | 10.6(6–13) | NA | PE | Ceramic; Metal | Osteolysis; revision | – | 6 |
Yalcin et al. [31] | Cohort study | 122 | 5.2 (2.7–6.3) | Posterolateral | PE; Cobalt-chrome | Cobalt-chrome | Migration; HHS | – | 7 |