Outcomes and complications of the reamer irrigator aspirator versus traditional iliac crest bone graft harvesting: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Oliva, Francesco; Migliorini, Filippo; Cuozzo, Francesco; Torsiello, Ernesto; Hildebrand, Frank; Maffulli, Nicola

doi:10.1186/s10195-021-00612-9

Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology

Official Journal of the Italian Society of Orthopaedics and Traumatology

Table 2 Generalities and patient baselines of the included studies

From: Outcomes and complications of the reamer irrigator aspirator versus traditional iliac crest bone graft harvesting: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Authors, year	Journal	Type of study	CMS	Follow-up (months)	Treatment	Patients (n)	Mean age (years)	Female (n)
Alhmann et al., 2002 [9]	J Bone Joint Surg Am	Retrospective	67	60.0	ICBG	88	46.2	13
					ICBG
Almaiman et al., 2013 [16]	Craniomaxillofac Trauma Reconstr	Retrospective	67	12.0	ICBG	372		172
Banwart et al., 1995 [39]	Spine	Retrospective	68	66.0	ICBG	180	26.3	115
Belthur et al., 2008 [17]	Clin Orthop Relat Res	Retrospective	64	9.1	RIA	41	44.9	18
				20.2	ICBG	40	46.4	17
Beirne et al., 1996 [31]	Int J Oral Maxilofac Surg	Retrospective	67	12.0	ICBG	137		60
Burstein et al., 2000 [40]	Plastic Reconstr Surg	Retrospective	60		ICBG	55	11.2	22
Calori et al., 2014 [2]	Injury	Retrospective	54	12.0	RIA	35	50.17	12
					ICBG	35	53.62	14
Carlock et al., 2019 [35]	J Am Acad Orthop Surg	Retrospective	65	12.0	ICBG	242	58.3	107
Conway et al., 2014 [41]	Orthopedics	Retrospective	51	6.5	RIA	7	45.0	3
David et al., 2003 [42]	J Spinal Disord Tech	Retrospective	70	26.5	ICBG	107	42.75	43
Dawson et al., 2014 [24]	J Orthop Trauma	RCT	82	56.9	RIA	56	41.3	23
					ICBG	57	47.4	22
Delawi et al., 2007 [43]	Spine	Retrospective	70	87.6	ICBG	71	47.6	22
Deorio et al., 2005 [27]	Foot Ankle Int	Retrospective	78	74.4	ICBG	134
Dimar et al., 2009 [32]	Spine J	Retrospective	62	24.0	ICBG	194	52.3
Fernyhough et al., 1992 [44]	Spine	Retrospective	67	12.0	ICBG	147		50
Finkemeir et al., 2010 [45]	Orthop Clinic North Am	Retrospective	61	18.0	RIA	23	50.0	10
Goulet et al., 1997 [29]	Clinic Orthop Relat Res	Retrospective	61		ICBG	170	41.0	60
Han et al., 2015 [18]	Injury	Retrospective	67	54.0	RIA	57		3
Haubruck et al., 2018 [46]	PloS One	Retrospective	75	75.0	RIA	306	54.0	113
Hill et al., 1999 [47]	Aust N Z J Surg	Retrospective	62	37.0	ICBG	73	38.0	31
Kanakaris et al., 2011 [37]	Injury	Prospective	62	6.0	RIA	42	45.5	14
Kim et al., 2009 [48]	Spine J	Prospective	72	12.0	ICBG	110	50.4	56
Kusnezov et al., 2017 [49]	SICOT J	Retrospective	61	13.3	RIA	15	41.1	5
Le Baron et al., 2019 [23]	Orthop Traumatol Surg Res	Prospective	74	22.1	RIA	30	38.9	9
				56.7	ICBG	29	35.3	6
Loeffler et al., 2012 [50]	J Bone Joint Surg Am	Prospective	74	12.0	ICBG	92		31
Mccall et al., 2010 [20]	Orthop Clinic North Am	Prospective	64	48.0	RIA	21	30.6	8
Marchand et al., 2017 [26]	J Orthop Trauma	Retrospective	62	13.0	RIA	61	51.0	50
					ICBG	47	54.0
Merrit et al., 2010 [51]	Spine	Retrospective	64	24.0	ICBG	92	62.0	60
Metsemakers et al., 2019 [52]	Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg	Retrospective	72	84.0	RIA	72	45.4	23
Mirovski et al., 2000 [53]	Spine	Prospective	72	24.0	ICBG	60	39.8
Nodzo et al., 2014 [25]	Int Orthop	Retrospective	47		RIA	29	49.4	21
					ICBG	27	49.3	21
On Salawu et al., 2017 [36]	Malays Orthop J	Prospective	77	13.0	ICBG	86	40.8	33
Pollock et al., 2008 [28]	Eur Spine j	Retrospective	64	19.8	ICBG	77	46.1	47
Qvick et al., 2013 [3]	Injury	Retrospective	70	48.0	RIA	204	50.0	88
Robertson et al., 2001 [54]	Spine	Prospective	78	12.0	ICBG	106	47.4	72
Schizas et al., 2009 [55]	Int Orthop	Prospective	69	36.0	ICBG	59
Schwartz et al., 2009 [56]	Health Qual Life Outcomes	Prospective	78	42.9	ICBG	170	51.1
Silber et al., 2003 [33]	Spine	Retrospective	70	48.0	ICBG	134		75
Westrich et al., 2001 [30]	J Orthop Trauma	Retrospective	63		RIA	390	47.9	183
Younger et al., 1989 [8]	J Orthop Trauma	Retrospective	58	11.0	ICBG	239	33.0	86

RIA reamer irrigator aspirator, ICBG iliac crest bone graft, RCT randomized controlled trial

Back to article page