Official Journal of the Italian Society of Orthopaedics and Traumatology
Table 3 Summary of literature data on the use of preliminary traction in the treatment of congenital dislocation of the hip
From: The effectiveness of preliminary traction in the treatment of congenital dislocation of the hip
Authors | Journal, year of publication | Number of hips (traction vs no traction) | Use of preliminary traction | Incidence of AVN (%) | Length of follow-up | Recommendations for traction use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Weinstein, Ponseti (Iowa, USA) [14] | JBJS Am, 1979 | 10 vs 12 hips | Comparative | 10% vs 10% | 3.5 y | Not recommended |
Kahle et al. (Utah, USA) [28] | JBJS Am, 1990 | 47 hips | No | 3.5% | > 2 y | Not recommended |
Fish et al. (Michigan, USA) [16] | JPO, 1991 | Survey (POSNA) | Comparative | Not reported | Not reported | Recommended |
Tavares et al. (Iowa, USA) [29] | JPO, 1994 | 27 hips | Yes | 7.4% | Not reported | Recommended |
Quinn et al. (Connecticut, USA) [17] | JPO, 1994 | 75 hips | Yes | 6.7% | 5.4 y | Not recommended |
Daoud et al. (Algeria) [30] | JBJS Am, 1996 | 50 hips | Yes | 10% | 4 y | Recommended |
Weinstein (Iowa, USA) [18] | CORR, 1997 | Update | No | Not reported | Not reported | Not recommended |
Langenskiold et al. (Finland) [20] | JPO, 2000 | 176 vs 86 hips | Comparative | 2.8% vs 46.5% | 13.1 y | Recommended |
Kutlu et al. (Turkey) [19] | JPO, 2000 | 89 vs 65 hips | Comparative | 4.5% vs 0% | 5 y vs 2.5 y | Not recommended |
Yamada et al. (Japan) [21] | JBJS Br, 2003 | 62 hips | Yes | 1.6% | > 2 y | Recommended |
Sibinski et al. (Poland) [22] | Int Orthop, 2006 | 107 vs 48 hips | Comparative | 1.9% vs 14.6% | 19.5 y | Recommended |
Rampal et al. (France) [23] | JBJS Br, 2008 | 47 hips | Yes | 2.1% | 14.3 y | Recommended |
Terjesen et al. (Norway) [11] | JBJS Am, 2014 | 90 hips | Yes | 10% | 51.6 y | Recommended |
Schur et al. (California, USA) [33] | J Child Orthop, 2016 | 70 hips | Yes | 35% | 5 y | Not recommended |
Sucato et al. (Texas, USA) [12] | JPO, 2017 | 276 vs 66 hips | Comparative | 18% vs 8% | 10.4 y | Not recommended |
Park et al. (Korea) [31] | Ther Clin Risk Manag, 2018 | Systematic review (683 hips) | Comparative | 5–47% vs 0–72% | Not reported | Not recommended |
Wicart et al. (France) [32] | J Child Orthop, 2018 | Review | Yes | 2% to 72% | Not reported | Recommended |
Li et al. (China) [13] | JPO B, 2019 | Systematic review (440 hips) | Comparative | 14% vs 14.5% | 3.1 y | Not recommended |