Official Journal of the Italian Society of Orthopaedics and Traumatology
Table 1 Spreadsheet of included articles
Study (year) | Study design | No. of patients | Male:female | Age (years) Mean (range) | Nonoperative:operative | Follow-up duration (months) | Nonunion | Functional assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bakir et al. [23] (2017) | Retrospective case series | 17 | 12:5 | 57 (23–93) | 13:4 | –a | 0 | – |
Ogawa et al. [20] (2017) | Case report | 1 | 0:1 | 74 | 1:0 | 36 | 0 | OSS 47b ASES 91.6c Quick DASH 5.0d |
Salipas et al. [9] (2016) | Retrospective case series | 68 | 53:15 | 53.5 (16–94)e | 68:0 | 36 (12–72) | 2 (n = 30) | ASES 80.3 (n = 33) SSV 77 (10–100)f Pain score 1.9 |
Varelas et al. [17] (2015) | Case report | 1 | 0:1 | 68 | 0:1 | 12 | 0 | DASH: 5 |
Wang et al. [24] (2015) | Case report | 1 | 1:0 | 40 | 0:1 | 12 | 0 | Full pain-free ROM |
Sethi et al. [25] (2012) | Case report | 1 | 0:1 | 70 | 1:0 | 8 | 0 | – |
Oe et al. [15] (2012) | Retrospective case series | 10 | 9:1 | 33.9 (16–73) | 0:10 | 38 (14–52) | 1 | DASH 13.5 (0–66.7) |
Bartonicek et al. [10] (2010) | Case report | 5 | 5:0 | 41.6 (19–66) | 2:3 | 17 (12–34) | 0 | DASH: 27 (33.3 + 27.1) Pain score 0.6 |
Gille et al. [18] (2010) | Case report | 1 | 0:1 | 21 | 0:1 | 16 | 0 | Pain free ROM |
Miller et al. [26] (2009) | Case report | 1 | 1:0 | 17 | 0:1 | 6 | 0 | Pain-free ROM |
McKenna et al. [19] (2009) | Case report | 1 | 1:0 | 23 | 0:1 | 2.5 | 0 | Pain-free ROM |
Brunner et al. [22] (2008) | Case report | 1g | 1:0 | 21 | 0:2 | 3 | 0 | Pain-free ROM |
Throckmorton et al. [5] (2007) | Retrospective case series | 55 | 44:11 | 46.3 (19–88) | 51:4 | 15.5 (n = 32) | 1 (n = 10) | 72% no or mild pain |
Haywood and Clasper [16] (2005) | Case report | 1 | 1:0 | 54 | 0:1 | 3 | 0 | – |
Nowak et al. [4] (2005) | Prospective observational study | 4 | – | – | 4:0 | 6 | 1 | – |
Robinson et al. [3] (2004) | Prospective observational study | 24 | 18:6 | 52 (29–77) | 24:0 | 6 | 2 | – |
Robinson [1] (1998) | Retrospective case series | 28 | 22:6 | 37.2 (13–78) | 28:0 | – | 0 | – |