Skip to main content

Official Journal of the Italian Society of Orthopaedics and Traumatology

Table 1 Comparison of the demographic and postoperative data for both groups

From: Intramedullary nailing versus proximal plating in the management of closed extra-articular proximal tibial fracture: a randomized controlled trial

 

IMN group (group A)

PTP group (group B)

p value

Sex

 Male

14

18

0.961

 Female

5

7

 

Age

39 (18–65)

36 (19–62)

0.525

AO/OTA classification (OTA 41-A2/A3)

10/9

10/15

0.405

Operative time (h)

81.57 (60–110)

87.91 (60–120)

0.082

Hospital stay (days)

4.1 (2–8)

5.3 (3–10)

0.035

Union time (weeks) or time required before full weight-bearing (weeks)

18.26 (10–30)

22.84 (16–34)

0.004

Infection

0

2

0.738

Malalignment

 Coronal plane

2.77 (0–7)

2.08 (0–8)

0.296

 Sagittal plane

2.57 (0–8)

2.19 (0–9)

0.415

 Range of motion of knee

119.7 (90–150)

115.2 (80–150)

0.462

 Delayed union/nonunion

2/1

0/1

0.849